News Summary
California colleges, including CSULB and PCC, are holding special graduation events for undocumented students called ‘UndocuGraduation.’ These ceremonies celebrate the achievements of students who navigate challenges related to their immigration status. While supporters advocate for such inclusive recognition, critics argue it may alienate students who have followed legal immigration procedures. Amidst federal scrutiny, the trend of identity-focused graduation events continues to emerge, recognizing the diverse backgrounds of graduates and their significant academic accomplishments.
Long Beach, California – In a move that has sparked significant debate, several California colleges, including California State University Long Beach (CSULB) and Pasadena City College (PCC), are hosting special graduation ceremonies aimed specifically at undocumented students, referred to as ‘UndocuGraduation.’ These events are designed to celebrate the achievements of students who have overcome barriers related to their immigration status. However, the ceremonies have faced criticism from some quarters, claiming that they undermine the efforts of students who have followed legal immigration processes.
CSULB’s ‘Beyond Borders Graduation Ceremony’ is being touted as a celebration of resilience for Hispanic and undocumented graduates. The university asserts that the graduates from this class have faced significant adversity and have triumphed against the odds, thereby warranting recognition through the ceremony. Meanwhile, PCC is set to host its own UndocuGraduation next week, which includes a ceremony, dinner, and entertainment, all organized by its Dream Resource Center. This center provides various support services for undocumented students, including legal assistance and academic counseling.
The response to these events has been mixed. Some critics, including Emily Sturge from Campus Reform, argue that the UndocuGraduation ceremonies send a negative message to legally documented students, likening the celebrations to a “slap in the face” for those who have adhered to immigration laws, specifically those on student visas. Advocates, however, emphasize that the UndocuGraduation initiatives create inclusive spaces for marginalized students, who often face distinct challenges in their educational journeys.
Several institutions across California, such as California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, are also participating in this trend by offering their own versions of UndocuGraduation. The move towards identity-specific graduation events has been identified as a growing trend in educational institutions throughout the United States, aimed at acknowledging the diverse backgrounds of students and providing recognition for their achievements in a culturally relevant manner. This year, PCC’s UndocuGraduation will uniquely honor its undocumented graduates, amidst a broader array of identity-focused ceremonies that also cater to Black, Asian, and LGBT graduates.
The U.S. Department of Education has raised concerns providing a memo indicating that graduation ceremonies based on race could be considered illegal segregation. This positions these identity-focused events within a contentious legal framework, especially following a recent Supreme Court ruling that addresses college admissions. Despite federal scrutiny and ongoing discussions about legality and appropriateness, many educators in California continue to advocate for and hold these ceremonies as crucial celebrations of diversity and educational accomplishments.
In light of potential immigration enforcement issues, some organizers have expressed worries about local authorities attending these events. Adjustments have been made to the way these celebrations are presented to remain unobtrusive and focused on community recognition. The UndocuGraduation events are designed to include allies in the celebrations, fostering a sense of community support among all participants. Many graduates have voiced that these ceremonies hold great significance, as they not only honor academic achievements but also celebrate cultural heritage and family background.
The trend toward culturally relevant graduation events continues to gain traction as many academic institutions strive to provide meaningful recognition to first-generation students and undocumented graduates alike. With many schools committed to maintaining these special ceremonies, participants often highlight their experiences of being acknowledged and supported during their academic journeys. This approach allows them to incorporate family traditions and cultural expressions into their graduation celebrations, exemplifying the importance of recognizing diverse student experiences in the educational landscape.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Additional Resources
- Turn to 10: UndocuGraduation in California
- Wikipedia: Undocumented Immigration in the United States
- News 4 San Antonio: Backlash Over UndocuGraduation
- Google Search: College Graduation Ceremonies
- USA Today: College Graduation Celebrations
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Graduation Ceremony
- LAist: College Graduation Trends in California
- Google News: Undocumented Student Graduation
- Washington Examiner: Racially Focused Graduation Ceremonies
- Google Scholar: Graduation Ceremonies for Undocumented Students
